To the editor:
In the din of the campaigns for president, Congress, mayor, and City Council, the races for Alexandria School Board are largely being ignored.
But on Monday in Del Ray, residents will have an opportunity to hear the candidates in District A discuss some of the key issues affecting our schools. The forum will be held from 7:30 to 9 p.m. at the Mount Vernon Community School auditorium. Childcare will be provided.
The six District A candidates, who are vying for three seats, will certainly have some vexing issues to debate.
Superintendent Mort Sherman has said that “eliminating academic achievement differences among race, income, disability and language subgroups must be the highest priority.” He called this “an educational and moral imperative.” Schools across America are struggling to close these achievement gaps. Do the candidates believe that Alexandria is making progress? If so, what are the best examples? If not, where and in what areas do we need to do more?
Given the major focus on closing achievement gaps, do the candidates believe that the school system is doing enough to support students who are achieving at high levels? If not, how would they change or improve programs for the most gifted students?
Many parents want to understand how Alexandria measures the success of its schools. They also want to know if they are sending their child to a good school. What measures of achievement are now being used? Are they adequate or are additional metrics needed?
Because of big enrollment increases in recent years, Alexandria’s elementary schools are bursting at the seams. But these enrollment increases appear to be limiting elementary school choice. How would the candidates address the capacity challenges facing the schools and their effects on parental choice?
Despite increasing enrollment, there is a perception that some parents continue to question the quality of Alexandria’s public schools and send their children to private school or to a public school elsewhere. Is this perception accurate, and if so, what can and should the school system do, if anything, to convince these families to stay in Alexandria schools?
In an August 2011 column, Superintendent Sherman stated that, “Our community and students deserve candor and a complete picture when it comes to looking at school and division performance.” How do the candidates grade the school administration on communication, transparency and candor? If they give a grade of less than A, what changes to improve the situation would they recommend?
One of the school board’s major responsibilities is overseeing and managing the superintendent. What do the candidates believe is the right relationship between the school board and the superintendent?
Another one of the school board’s major responsibilities is developing and overseeing the school system’s budget. How would the candidates work to restrain costs while ensuring that students receive the services they need?
There is pressure on school systems to develop rigorous teacher evaluation systems. Virginia requires that 40 percent of a teacher’s evaluation be based on student outcomes. Because the state allows districts some flexibility in determining those outcomes, what makes sense for Alexandria?
After the U.S. Department of Education designated T.C Williams High School a persistently low-achieving school in 2010, significant changes were made. To what degree have these reforms been successful? Do the candidates believe that additional steps need to be taken? If so, what?
Is the school system doing a good job at retaining good teachers and principals, or could more be done, such as more generously rewarding high-performers?
Is the school system doing all it can to prevent students from dropping out of school? If not, what more could be done?
These are difficult questions, but ones we hope the candidates will grapple with.
Bill Hendrickson
President, Del Ray Citizens Association
Edmund Lewis
12:38 pm on Sunday, October 7, 2012
Very thoughtful questions which need to be asked and should continue to be asked well past the election this November. Another question should be raised which impacts the point raised about retaining teahcers: Why have ACPS teachers not received a cost of living increase under this superintendent?
While costs have risen in all areas of living, teachers are actually taking home less money this year than last year (paying more in healthcare and retirement costs). That while the school board pays the superintendent more than the governor of our state, provides a car stipend for the superintendent to drive a Mercedes SUV, and doles out $40,000 in tax sheltered annuity payments to the superintendent.
Gail G
12:27 pm on Monday, October 8, 2012
I can't stress enough how important this school board election is and it is completely overshadowed by the other elections. There is no race in District C as there are only three candidates, but if you live in A, consider voting for Bill Campbell and Karen Graf, and if you live in B, consider voting for Kelly Carmichael Booz and Justin Keating. There is a candidates debate for B tonight, Monday October 8, at 7:30 at Beverly Hills Community Methodist Church, 3512 Old Dominion Boulevard.
David
12:53 pm on Monday, October 8, 2012
To clarify, the District A debate is also being held tonight Monday, October 8, at 7:30 p.m. at the Mount Vernon Community School auditorium, 2601 Commonwealth Avenue. Childcare will be provided.
this is just their stepping stone
1:20 pm on Monday, October 8, 2012
I think it's pretty clear for any person living around me Bill - "Many parents want to... know if they are sending their child to a good school. " My school is Jefferson Houston. It's unaccredited. Appreciate the help Bill, but I think I got this one.
Bill Campbell
1:17 am on Tuesday, October 9, 2012
I think Bill's questions were thoughtful and consistent with those of many parents in our communities. Accreditation is not a strong predictor of student success. Parent education and income level's are solid predictors. School choice for parents, one of the most important decisions that they will ever make, should center around salient points such as safety, quality teachers and a child's level of enthusiasm and excitement for the school. Other considerations include class size and resources/child. J-H has great teachers and the smallest classes in the City. A hidden gem for some, a sad failure for many under-involved families. My boys attended J-H and they will do fine. The world's foremost pediatric surgeon went to one of the lowest achieving public schools in inner city Baltimore. SOL, AYP, accreditation, we are all still trying to figure out their relevance especially in terms of their value to a family attempting to make such a crucial decision for their child. We have a lot of work to do for many of our students and families throughout ACPS, especially at J-H. I encourage parents to decide what items are most important to them and their individual child's needs. J-H could be a gem.